hoose either the Gibbs or Marquez essay to write on for this discussion, but read both.

By August 7th 12pm central, post your response to the following questions in 2-3 paragraphs:

• Summarize one counter argument and explain how it directly opposes the author’s thesis.
• Evaluate how the author argues against this opposing viewpoint. Is the refutation convincing? Why or why not?
• Present another potential counter argument that is not addressed in the essay.